At what age should we choose Velcro over laces for kids' shoes?

For toddlers (1-3) we generally recommend Velcro for speed, safety and easier fastening; in early primary (4-7) many children still benefit from Velcro or hybrid designs while they develop fine motor skills, and laces become more appropriate from around 8+ when a closer, adjustable fit is often needed.

How do we test whether a shoe’s fastening gives a secure fit?

Fasten the shoe, have the child jump, run a short distance and walk on a slight incline; if the heel lifts more than a finger’s width the fastening or last may not be secure enough and you should try a different option.

Which fastening works better for sport and active play?

Laces usually give a closer, incremental fit that stabilises the heel during multi-directional sport, while well-designed Velcro straps or hybrid lace-plus-Velcro styles can work for general playground play and offer quicker entry.

How do local conditions in South Africa affect fastening performance over time?

Dust, sand and frequent washing can reduce performance: Velcro attracts lint and grit so wider hooks and easy-clean straps help, while laces can fray so round, waxed laces are more durable for our varied conditions.

Should we prioritise convenience or fit when buying school shoes?

Match the fastening to the child’s stage and school requirements: prioritise quick entry like Velcro for younger children and busy mornings, but choose laces or hybrid designs where a snug, adjustable fit and formal neatness are needed.

Velcro vs laces for kids' shoes - which fastening is

Why fastening choice matters for kids' shoes

We focus on the small decisions that make daily life easier: how a shoe fastens affects independence, foot security, play performance and how long a pair stays comfortable. Choosing between Velcro and laces is not just about convenience - it’s about matching a shoe’s purpose to a child’s stage of development and the local rhythms of South African life, from school runs to weekend braais and after-school sport.

Quick factors to consider

Age and motor skills - younger children often need simpler fastenings.
Activity - the fastening should match planned use (playground, running, formal school).
Fit and foot support - some fastenings give a closer, adjustable fit.
Care and durability - sand, dust and frequent washing change how fastenings perform.
Cost and replacement - consider how easy it is to repair or replace parts.

How we think about stages (age-focused guide)

We break choices into broad stages so decisions are practical: toddlers (1-3), early primary (4-7), and older kids (8+). Each stage has typical needs rather than strict rules - children develop at different rates.

Toddlers (1-3): independence and safety are key. Velcro helps carers secure shoes quickly and lets little ones learn to pull straps themselves.
Early primary (4-7): developing fine motor skills mean some kids can tie laces, but many still benefit from Velcro or a mix (laces with a Velcro strap) for sport and school uniform needs.
Older kids (8+): laces become important where a close, adjustable fit matters - especially for running or multi-directional sports.

For practical shopping, matching the fastening to the shoe type helps: casual sneakers and school shoes often work well with Velcro for younger kids, while performance trainers and some school styles benefit from laces for a snugger fit.

If you’re browsing options, our Kids category gives a wide view of styles and sizes with both fastening types.

Kids

Fit, foot health and fastening mechanics

We prioritise a secure but comfortable fit. Laces allow incremental tightening along the instep and forefoot, which helps stabilise the heel and reduce slippage in active play. Velcro straps can produce a secure hold when placed correctly across the midfoot, but they depend on strap width and the quality of the closure.

A practical tip from our experience: when trying shoes in store or at home, fasten and have the child jump, run a short distance and walk on a slight incline (a step). If the heel lifts more than a finger’s width, try a different fastening or a different last. For formal school shoes where polish and neatness matter, choose construction and materials that keep the strap or laces tidy through wear.

Everyday wear and maintenance

South African kids often wear shoes across varied conditions - dusty playgrounds, rainy days and long school terms. That reality affects how fastenings perform over time.

Velcro attracts lint and grit; look for wider hooks and easy-clean straps to keep them functional longer.
Laces can fray; consider round, waxed laces for durability and ease of tying.
Hybrid designs (lace-up with a top Velcro strap) combine quick entry with adjustable fit for play and formal use.

Price-wise, expect many reliable kids' shoes with Velcro or laces in the R200-R1 000 range depending on brand and build; specialized performance shoes for sport sit at the higher end. These are rough ranges to help budgeting - actual prices vary by brand and retailer.

Add as a preferred source on Google

Safety, independence and learning to tie laces

We value independence. Learning to tie laces is a useful skill, but it doesn’t need to be rushed. Many schools allow Velcro for younger grades; others expect laces by a certain year. Pair practice with real-life moments: try learning on a relaxed day, using chunky, easy-to-handle laces and a simple knot method. If quick entry matters (morning routines, taxis, crèches), stick with Velcro until tying is consistent.

When to choose Velcro

Priority on speed and ease (parents and kids).
Young children still developing fine motor skills.
Sturdy play shoes where a single wide strap is enough to secure the foot.
School uniforms that require neat, simple closures.

When to choose laces

Need for a tailored fit, especially for active sports and long walks.
Older children who can tie reliably and prefer that look.
Shoes designed with performance lasts where the upper and sole demand incremental tension.

For mixed needs, we often recommend hybrid styles: secure lacing for a customised fit with a top Velcro strap for quick fastening at the end of the day. These are practical for school sports and weekend play.

Practical shopping checklist

Try shoes on with the socks your child will wear to school or sport.
Check fit with the chosen fastening - tighten and test movement.
Look for wide Velcro straps and strong stitching or for durable, low-fray laces.
Ask about replaceable parts (laces, insoles) so the shoe lasts longer.

If you’d like specific styles while you shop, our Kids shoes collection includes both Velcro and lace-up options across casual, school and sports styles - a helpful place to compare real stock and prices.

Shoes

A quick real-world scenario

We recently helped a parent choosing between a Velcro school shoe and a lace-up trainer for an energetic seven-year-old. The school required a smart black shoe for weekdays but allowed trainers for sport. The practical solution was two pairs: a neat lace-up school shoe (teacher request) and a Velcro trainer for after-school play and shorter mornings. This split approach keeps mornings simple and ensures performance where it matters.

Consideration: if you rely on taxis or have tightly packed morning routines, favour fastenings that reduce time at the door. For weekend sports or hiking, favour lace-up trainers for a secure fit.

Sources

We hope this helps you choose with confidence. If you want to compare styles side by side, start at our Kids shoes collection or browse the related article about kids' sneaker styles for extra guidance.

Kids' Nike Safari sneakers: styles, sizes and smart shopping tips

Velcro vs laces for kids' shoes - which fastening is right?

Match fastening to age

Why Choose Bash?

Free Delivery

30-Day Returns

Nationwide Support

Why Choose Bash?

Free Delivery

30-Day Returns

Nationwide Support

Think activity first

Care and longevity

Why fastening choice matters for kids' shoes

Quick factors to consider

How we think about stages (age-focused guide)

Fit, foot health and fastening mechanics

Everyday wear and maintenance

Safety, independence and learning to tie laces

When to choose Velcro

When to choose laces

Practical shopping checklist

A quick real-world scenario

Sources

Mmaphefo

Ukhona

Sambesiwe

Kamo

"Micayla"

Sabelo

Meagan

Bat

Anotha

Tshepiso

Elisa

Nqobile

Nicky

Melaney

Thina

Gwayimane

Phumelelo

Fenkie

Roxanne

Charlize

Refilwe

Dimane

Seth

Neil

Kirsti

Fatima

Nicolette

Ronel

Inge

Valerie

Adri

Chadley

Makhosonke

Mabel

Simo

Sharon

Nobuhle

Angelique Davis

Thabile

Arlene

Kgomotso

Kgosi

Steven

Kago

Reitumetse

Anina

Azwihangwisi

Marlene

Nkensane

Moreblessings

Palesa

Nonkasazana

Talifhani

Thandi

Vuyo

Elanie

Steady